We may earn commissions on purchases made through qualifying links, at no extra charge to you. For more information, check out our Disclaimer.

Ovens are the most common appliance of American kitchens. Not only are they truly versatile but extremely user-friendly. Simply set temperature and time, and the machine will do wonders. But apart from having a good electrical appliance, it is important to use the right baking tools for a flawless cooking experience. And if you love baking then we’ve picked some best rimmed baking sheets.

What is a rimmed baking sheet?

We’ve all heard of half sheets, they are common among bakers. But little that you know, baking sheets also come in various types. There are aluminum, steel-layered, insulated, nonstick baking sheets, etc. All these types have different shapes and design that makes them ideal for a special type of baking. And rimmed baking sheet common type among them due to its size and design.

So what exactly a rimmed baking sheet is? From the name itself you can say it is a half sheet with a rim. And yes, rimmed sheets feature 1-inch high rims on all sides that keep the ingredients inside the pan while baking, preventing the oven surface from getting messy. But rim isn’t the only great thing about rimmed half sheets.

Many chefs and home bakers use a rimmed sheet instead of a thin aluminum baking sheet because of its solid construction. A rimmed unit is usually made of heavy-duty metal that is far more durable than thin aluminum pans. Large machines press the metal into a predefined shape with rims around, and the rimmed baking sheet is ready.

Best Rimmed Baking Sheet Review

Best Rimmed Baking Sheets

ProductsMaterialWeightPrice
Nordic Ware Baker's Half SheetAluminum1.65 Pounds Check Price
USA Pan Bakeware Half Sheet PanSteel2.30 Pounds Check Price
OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Half SheetSteel2.35 Pounds Check Price
Checkered Chef Baking Sheet and Rack SetStainless Steel2.50 Pounds Check Price
TeamFar Baking Sheet, Cookie SheetStainless Steel2.32 Pounds Check Price
SAVEUR SELECTS Rimmed Baking SheetsAlloy Steel1.90 Pounds Check Price
Bellemain Heavy Duty Half Sheet PanAluminum1.54 Pounds Check Price

And today, we’ve listed down some of the best rimmed half sheets for your oven use that will help you make great-tasting baked goods.

1) Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet

Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker's Half Sheet

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Trusted by professionals, Nordic Ware’s natural aluminum half sheet is a favorite among bakers. All thanks to its high-quality construction that remains flat even after years of use. The use of pure aluminum instead of metal mixtures makes Nordic Ware half sheet worth every single penny. You can worry-free keep on baking cookies, batch after batch, and will still find the sheet retain its original shape. It is not any random baking sheet, in fact, it is a workhorse that can be used for various types of baking.

While pure aluminum construction provides superior heat conductivity, the reinforced encapsulated steel rim prevents warping. Warping is common in a thin, cheaply made sheet which causes the ingredients inside to bake unevenly. And no one loves to eat half burnt and half raw fries. But uneven baking will not be an issue with Nordic Ware as the sturdy rolled edges won’t flex or bend in. And a flat base is ideal for various types of cooking such as oven fries, pizzas, homemade cookies, sheet pan dinner, etc.

Our Verdict

What makes Nordic Ware 43105AMZ worth buying?

  • Made of pure, uncoated, high-quality aluminum
  • Proudly made in the USA in Minneapolis
  • Shiny, non-porous aluminum provides nonstick abilities
  • Encapsulated solid core steel rim
  • 450 degrees F; maximum heat tolerance
  • Comes in a set of 2 with pan exterior dimensions, 17.88 x 12.88 x 1.06 inches
  • Compatible with parchment paper or silicone baking mats
  • Best rimmed baking sheets on Amazon with thousands of satisfied users

2) USA Pan Bakeware Half Sheet Pan, Warp Resistant

USA Pan Bakeware Half Sheet Pan

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Baked caramelized desserts are love to have. But things get a little difficult when you have to scrub the caramel off the cookie sheet. And as an immature baker, I know how much energy and time it takes to bring the shiny surface back. But now you can ease cleaning with the USA half sheet pan. Its patented silicone coating prevents the stubborn sticking of foods to the sheet surface. You can easily take out the baked good on the plate without much scraping. Plus, the silicone coating is all safe to use in the oven.

In addition to the nonstick coating, the USA Pan oven sheet features a unique rigged texture. Such a texture facilitates even hot air circulation and heat distribution that provides excellent results every time. From crispy oven fries to evenly baked cookies, the corrugates surface is perfect for both roasting and baking. You can prepare a tasty and healthy sheet pan supper for your family. Besides, the rim further assists in keeping the ingredients in place by protecting the unit against warp. The 1-inch high, steel wire incorporated rim provides extra strength in high temperatures.

Our Verdict

Why buy USA Pan 1050HS?

  • Heavy-guage aluminized steel construction
  • Silicone nonstick coating is PTFE, PFOA, and BPA-free
  • Sturdy reinforced steel wire rim
  • Unique fluted surface enhances nonstick properties
  • Best professional-grade nonstick rimmed baking sheet for making cookies to one-pan dinner
  • Baking surface dimensions: 17.25 x 12.25 x 1 inch
  • Affordable
  • Made in the USA

3) OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Half Sheet

OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Half Sheet

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Make a perfect baked meal for your family without experiencing any sticking with Oxo Good Grips nonstick half sheet. Instead of a flat base, Oxo 13 x 18 oven sheet features a micro-textured pattern. Such a pattern facilitates nonstick properties as well as minimizes direct surface contact. Also, it promotes hot airflow under the food which results in even baking or browning. Plus, the micropattern of the half sheet leaves beautiful marks on the dinner roll/ pizza base.

Oxo good grips nonstick half sheet is coated with a commercial-grade, double-layer, ceramic-reinforced coating. This provides the best nonstick capability. And a better nonstick capability means less scratching and staining on the cookie sheet. Besides, the square rolled edges provide extra strength and a secure grip to place and take the sheet out of the oven easily. Speaking of the oven, the unit is oven safe up to 450ºF. Do not use it in temperatures higher than that.

Our Verdict

Highlights of Oxo Good Grips 11160800:

  • Heavy-grade aluminized steel that is oven safe up to 450 degrees F
  • Micro-textured pattern enhances nonstick abilities
  • A dual-layer ceramic enforced nonstick coating is ideal for baking a wide variety of foods
  • Dishwasher-safe for easy cleanup
  • Durable square-rolled edges
  • Best rimmed oven pan for sheet cakes and a large batch of cookies
  • Swiss-engineered; Made in USA

4) Checkered Chef Baking Sheet and Rack Set for Baking

Checkered Chef Baking Sheet and Rack Set

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Once you get a good grip on baking cookies at home, you make them frequently. Besides good baking, it is important to cool cookies before you store them in an airtight container to ensure long shelf life. Cooling cookies on baking sheets takes more time so instead, buy a Checkered Chef baking sheet with a cooling rack. While aluminum construction of sheet provides superior heat conductivity, the 100% stainless steel cooling rack helps cool baked goods down in less time. Not only for cooling but you can safely use the steel rack in the oven.

The unit comes in pieces, i.e, rimmed tray and wire baking rack. The 18×13 cookie sheet with a depth of 1-inch is perfect for making large batches of baked goods. However, you can also use the 17×12 inch stainless steel rack for baking as it perfectly sits in the large rimmed tray. Certain recipes like baked chicken wings, bacon, etc cook evenly and taste well when cooked on a wire rack as it promotes heat circulation in all directions.

Our Verdict

Why go for Checkered Chef Single Tray and Rack?

  • 100% stainless steel cooling rack with no artificial coatings or treatments
  • Unique crossbar design prevents twisting and warping
  • The wire rack sits perfectly inside the half sheet for better baking
  • Handwashing of tray is recommended while the rack is safe to wash in dishwasher
  • Both cookie sheet and wire rack are oven safe up to 500ºF
  • Lightweight yet spacious
  • Best quality aluminum cookie sheet with stainless steel rack
  • Smooth and safe, rolled edge for better handling of the large pan

5) TeamFar Baking Sheet – Cookie Sheet Half Sheet

TeamFar Baking Sheet, 20’’×14’’×1’’, Cookie Sheet Half Sheet

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Bake delicious goods for your family with TeamFar large half sheets. Measuring 19.7 x 13.75 x 1.3 inches, the flat cookie sheets are made of high-quality 18/0 stainless steel. Though steel is a poor conductor as compared to aluminum, it is safer to bake things at high temperatures. With a quality steel-rimmed half sheet, there is no need to worry about the negative effects of aluminum or the infusion of toxic substances in your food. And the best part is, these xl baking sheets are dishwasher-safe which means you do not have to spend time scrubbing them in the kitchen sink.

The best part about 2 xl rimmed baking sheets is the size. You can bake a good quantity of food at a time to feed a crowd if you’ve got a double-decker oven. From fishes, ribs, cookies, bacon, vegetables, and bread, there are a lot of recipes you can make on the large tray. Besides, both the trays are 1.3-inch deep that prevents oil or juice from spilling out. And fewer spills and splatters means less time cleaning the oven after use.

Our Verdict

What makes TeamFar Half Sheet Pans worth the money?

  • Set of 2 pans measuring approx 20 inches are ideal for a big family
  • Deep full sides and rimmed edges keep juices and oil in the sheet itself
  • Thick and solid stainless steel construction
  • One of the best flat base stainless steel half sheets for residential baking
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Rust-free and warp-resistant performance for years
  • Shiny mirror finish results in less sticking and easy cleaning
  • Parchment paper compatible

6) SAVEUR SELECTS Set of 2 Rimmed Baking Sheets

SAVEUR SELECTS Set of 2 Rimmed Baking Sheets

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Experience the professional performance in style with Saveur Select’s set of 2 rimmed baking sheets. The two medium size trays can fit up to 18 cookies, enough for a family of 6. Instead of stainless steel or aluminum, these trays are made of carbon steel that provides fast, even heat distribution. Ultimately, you get evenly baked or browned goods that look just like the ones in the bakery.

Nonstick coating on heavy-gauge carbon steel material ensures easy lifting of food off the tray. No sticking to food on a sheet also ensures scratch and chip-resistant performance for years. Apart from the smooth black nonstick surface, the medium size half sheet features thick outer rims embossed with Saveur’s signature milled texture. This non-slip grip provides ultimate comfort to the user while putting or taking the hot tray out from the oven. And once the work is done, simply pop the unit in the dishwasher for effortless cleaning.

Our Verdict

Highlights of Saveur Selects T19-010-11:

  • Heavy-gauge carbon steel conducts heat quickly and evenly
  • Both the baking sheets are dishwasher safe
  • Oven-safe up to 450ºF
  • The large baking tray measures 11-inch long by 17-inch wide(including rims); enough to hold up to 18 cookies
  • Nonstick coating ensures the scratch-free output
  • Durable metal resists twisting and warping even after years of use
  • Professional black color
  • Designed in the USA

7) Bellemain Heavy Duty Aluminum Half Sheet Pan

Bellemain Heavy Duty Aluminum Half Sheet Pan

Read Customer Reviews Here »

A stainless or carbon steel tray can be expensive and if you’re not ready to spend dollars on a single baking tool then go for Bellemain aluminum half sheet pan. This heavy-duty baking tray costs under $20 and is perfect for home cooks. The thick aluminum construction won’t warp or rust like cheap thin sheets. In fact, high-quality construction ensures rust and warp-free performance of the thick tray for years. You can safely use the metal cookie tray in the oven to 450 degrees F.

On the downside, the Bellemain rust-proof aluminum cookie sheet is not dishwasher-friendly. But thanks to a smooth, flat, mirror-finish surface that is easy to wash under hot water. Use a nylon brush or sponge to remove the debris. And let the unit air dry completely before storing it away in the drawer to prevent rust. Apart from baking cookies, one-sheet meals, the unit is safe for roasting. You can try roasting veggies, chicken, etc, and make a delicious side dish.

Our Verdict

Why go for Bellemain TRTAZ11A?

  • Mirror-smoot baking surface
  • Thick-gauge aluminum construction
  • The aluminum pan is okay to bake, oven-fry, or roast ingredients
  • Deep rims keep the juices contained in the tray for mess-free cooking
  • Large 18″ x 13″ x 1″ tray
  • Reinforced, rolled, encapsulated steel rim prevents warping at higher temperatures
  • Best rated aluminum baking sheet for home use
  • Easy to handwash

How do I keep my baking sheet from warping?

Warping of a baking tray is a common phenomenon and many of us have experienced it at least once or many times. Warping happens due to exposure of metal to high temperatures. Heat penetrates inside the metal and causes them to bend/warp. And when a sheet undergoes frequent warping/bending, it simply cracks at some time. So is there any way to prevent the baking sheet from warping?

Well, you can take some precautions to avoid bending/warping of the tray. Firstly, do not expose the metal tray to extremely hot temperatures and cool it off instantly. Take the sheet out from the oven and let it rest on the countertop or other flat surface for a while. Natural cooling helps to bring the warped baking tray back to the original shape in some cases.

Do not overfill your baking tray. Sometimes, the weight of ingredients deforms the shape of the unit, plus, it becomes heavy to handle the hot tray out of the oven.

If possible, always handwash your rimmed baking tray. A gentle handwash ensures better cleaning and effective removal of stubborn mess from the surface. Also, the tray retains its shape when it is not exposed to harsh detergents and high temperatures inside the dishwashing machine.

You might also like:

Conclusion

Every baker deserves good quality baking tools and what could be better than a durable rimmed baking sheet that prevents spills inside the oven. The solid rims of the tray prevent warping or bending in high temperatures.

Besides, the presence of rims lets you make more than just cookies. You can prepare one-sheet meals, roast vegetables, etc, while nonstick rimmed half sheets are best for making caramelized desserts. Affordable and user-friendly, a rimmed baking sheet is a must to have in the kitchen of every serious baker.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here