We may earn commissions on purchases made through qualifying links, at no extra charge to you. For more information, check out our Disclaimer.

Hamilton Beach is one of the most popular toaster oven brands in North America. Their low-priced 4-slice toaster oven featuring a pizza oven, toast, broil, and bake settings makes them an ideal kitchen appliance.

If you’re one of those people who never skip breakfast then a toaster oven is a must-have appliance in your kitchen. While there are a bunch of options available, we’ve decided to stick with the Hamilton Beach toaster oven only. This is because of the long and good history of the brand. The way you toast your bread will no longer be boring with the best 4-slice toaster oven.

Before you jump to the reviews, the question is, do you need a 4-slice toaster oven? If you have a large family who loves to have toast in the morning then yes you should go for them. A good quality toaster oven offers other functions in addition to toasting. So not to worry as your not paying the money only for browning the slices of the bread.

Best Hamilton Beach 4-Slice Toaster Oven Reviews

You can get the best quality countertop 4-slice toaster oven without breaking your bank account, no matter if the brand is Hamilton Beach itself. Plus, many models feature a convection setting that bakes your desserts just like the large built-in oven but uses very little energy. At last, it is up to you whether you’d like to bake, broil or toast but we aim to help you find the best Hamilton Beach toaster oven that fulfills most of your requirements as well as is durable.

Best Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Toaster Oven Comparison

Hamilton Beach 314014-Slices1100 Watts Check Price
Hamilton Beach 311264-Slices1400 Watts Check Price
Hamilton Beach 31344D4-Slices1100 Watts Check Price
Hamilton Beach 31118R4-Slices 950 Watts Check Price
Hamilton Beach 311434-Slices1500 Watts Check Price

1) Hamilton Beach Countertop Large 4-Slice Toaster Oven & Pizza Maker, Stainless Steel (31401)

Hamilton Beach Countertop Large 4-Slice Toaster Oven 31401

Read Customer Reviews Here »

The classic design of Hamilton Beach 31401 is loved by many. It has a simple yet durable stainless steel exterior that is easy to wipe clean. Although it might look like a small toaster oven, its spacious interior can fit a 9-inch pizza easily. If not pizza, the metal rack can toast 4 bread slices at once for you to enjoy breakfast with your family. Speaking of the metal rack, you can adjust it to two positions for better control when cooking or reheating the food.

Large ovens require a lot of energy to circulate hot air evenly inside. But that’s not the case with this small Hamilton Beach countertop toaster oven. Thanks to its compact size that circulates heat fast and evenly. This helps to save a lot of energy when you’re baking cookies or lasagne for 2 people. On average, it uses up to 75 percent less energy and is 28% faster than a typical kitchen oven when it comes to reheating precooked food.

Time, temperature, and function are easy to set with the help of knobs on the side. The temperature ranges from 150 to 450 degrees. This is perfect for reheating frozen nuggets, bake a delicious pizza, crispy toasts, and much more. Plus, there’s a 30-minute timer with an automatic shutoff feature. No need to keep checking the oven as a ready bell lets you know when the timer is over and your baked good is ready.

Our Verdict


  • With three different settings, there’s an endless array of dishes you can make
  • Interior is large enough to fit a 9-inch pizza, 6 muffins, or even a casserole
  • Offers a broiling feature that is great for salmon and steaks
  • Best small toaster oven for kitchens where space is at a premium
  • Great for making small batches of nuggets, cookies, cupcakes, etc
  • Offers 2 rack position to set the food easily according to its height
  • The grill and tray is handy and easy to clean


  • Dials have tiny labels that are quite hard to read

Key Features:

  • 1100 watts
  • Stainless steel exterior
  • 3 functions
  • Adjustable temperature
  • Easy-to-use dials
  • Auto shutoff
  • 30-minute timer
  • Weighs 7.33 pounds

2) Hamilton Beach (31126) Toaster Oven, 4-Slice Convection Oven, Easy Reach

Hamilton Beach (31126) Toaster Oven, Convection Oven

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Cleaning a toaster oven is tiresome but an unskippable task. After all, you would not like the smell of previously cooked food into your fresh batch of cookies. But Hamilton Beach convection oven can save you from long hours of cleaning. And the credit goes to its roll-top door. Instead of opening down or on the side, the roll-top door opens up. This gives you a large opening which eases inserting a tray and accessing food.

Since the door opens above, it frees up your countertop space. So you can use it in your RV where the space is limited. The spacious interior of Hamilton Beach roll-top door lets you toast up to 6 slices of bread at once. If not toasts, the area is great to bake a 12-inch pizza for a family dinner night. Besides, you can easily open the door in case you wish to add delicate toppings or cheese later.

The best thing about 31126 Hamiton Beach Easy Reach toaster oven is you get to choose between bake and convection. While the bake function is great for baking cakes, dough, and desserts, convection is perfect to achieve that crispy golden-brown pizza crust. The crisp is the result of even heat circulation by a convection fan at the back. Not only does this cooks your food evenly from all sides but it also reduces cooking time by up to 25%.

Our Verdict


  • The crumb tray at the bottom is easy to remove and clean
  • There are 4 heating elements, two at the top and two on the bottom
  • Spacious enough to fit in 6 slices of toast
  • Convectional technology is perfect for pizza lovers
  • A built-in fan distributes heat evenly for a uniform temperature
  • Comes with a baking pan, baking tray, and a removable crumb tray
  • The best toaster oven for limited countertop space


  • Expensive
  • It is somewhat difficult to clean inside of glass door
  • Will take good countertop space

Key Features:

  • 1400 watts
  • Roll-top door
  • 4 cooking settings
  • Optional stay-on settings
  • 2 rack positions
  • 30-minute timer
  • Weighs 6 pounds

3) Hamilton Beach 31344D Easy Reach With Roll-Top Door Toaster Oven 4-Slice

Hamilton Beach 31344D Easy Reach With Roll-Top Door 4 slice Toaster Oven

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Rolltop doors are all beautiful and convenient until grease or sauce spatters on it. Then it becomes a bit difficult to reach inside of the glass door and clean the mess. So Hamilton Beach came up with a solution, a removable glass door. Yes, you can completely detach the glass door of this Hamiton Beach 4-slice toaster oven. This cuts down the cleaning time by half. Be it juices, grease, or melted cheese, nothing is difficult to clean off the roll-top glass door.

Contoured knobs let you select the appropriate function from bake, broil, and toast. The smooth contour lets you set the knob at the correct position. However, there are only 2 knobs to set three different functions. While the upper knob is specific to set temperature, the lower one does the work of both function selection and timer. Simply rotate the knob past 10 to set the time.

Normally, crumb trays of large oven detach from the bottom. This is quite a cumbersome process as there are high chances you might get the floor or countertop messy. But the mess is not the case with Hamilton Beach easy reach toaster oven. Instead of the bottom, the crumb tray slides out from the front. This eases the cleanup of both the machine and the crumb tray.

Our Verdict


  • A mini toaster oven that will not take up much countertop space
  • Fits 4 slices of toast or a 9-inch pizza
  • Safe design
  • Despite the small size, the oven offers 2 rack position for better cooking of the food
  • Easy-to-use contoured knobs
  • Spills and splatters are a breeze to clean


  • A single knob to set function and time can be a bit confusing in the beginning
  • Lacks the convection setting
  • The sides get too hot to touch

Key Features:

  • Removable glass door
  • Contoured knobs
  • 2 rack positions
  • 3 functions
  • Front-access crumb tray
  • Auto shutoff
  • Weighs 11.2 pounds

4) Hamilton Beach, Black Proctor Silex 4-Slice Toaster Oven, (31118R)

Hamilton Beach, Black Proctor Silex 4-Slice Toaster Oven

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Living in a dorm does not mean you couldn’t enjoy crispy toasts or delicious pizzas. We understand the space is very limited in small apartments and dorms, so a compact toaster oven like Hamilton Beach 31118R will be perfect. The space-saving size of the unit fits easily on a small countertop. Yet the interior provides ample space to toast 4 slices of bread or defrost 2 personal pizzas.

You do not need to look for accessories separately as it already includes a baking pan and a metal rack. While the metal rack is perfect to toast up to 4 slices of bread at once, baking pan is great for cooking or warming cookies, biscuits, rolls, leftovers, etc. And similar to many high-end models, this budget oven toaster also offers 3 cooking settings. You can choose from toast, bake, or broil.

Our Verdict


  • Perfect for small apartment and dorm use
  • Includes a baking pan for cooking and warming foods
  • Handy broiler for cooking versatility
  • The machine shuts off automatically to save energy
  • Large opening for easy access
  • A ready bell indicates when the function is over


  • The crumb tray is not removable
  • Sometimes it toasts unevenly
  • The glass door should be handled carefully

Key Features:

  • Aluminum construction
  • 15-minute timer
  • Automatic shutoff
  • Drop-down crumb tray
  • Cool-touch exterior
  • 3 functions
  • Weighs 2.68 lbs

5) Hamilton Beach 4-Slice Countertop Toaster Oven with Bake Pan, Stainless Steel (31143)

Hamilton Beach 4-Slice Countertop Toaster Oven with Bake Pan

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Beautiful, classy, and sturdy, this Hamilton Beach stainless steel toaster oven is a great addition to your kitchen countertop. While the shiny steel exterior accounts for durability, the chrome-plated dials enhance beauty. This oven can be a sophisticated staple in any kitchen. Not only looks, but Hamiton Beach 31143 also offers a wide array of functions that help with everyday cooking and baking.

Unlike other models, that offer a maximum of 2 or 3 functions, this 4-slice oven offers 5 functions. Use the toast feature to prepare crisp toast, or make a batch of chewy chocolate cookies with the bake settings. Turn the knob to broil and you can enjoy melted cheese on your garlic bread or simply brown the fish. And there’s a bagel option for all bagel lovers that make the toasts the bagel the way it should be. Toasty cut on the side and warmed round side.

Convection setting helps to bake food like a pro. Adjustable temperature from 150-450 degrees F with a 30-minute timer lets you bake a variety of soft to crispy foods. Or switch to stay-on function that gives you better control when cooking. Also, you can adjust the metal rack to two positions based on food height or cooking settings.

Our Verdict


  • Three easy to grip knobs makes selecting your settings quick and effortless
  • It can easily hold up to 4 slices of bread and fits a 9-inch pizza
  • One of the best toaster oven under $100
  • Includes an oven rack, bake pan, and a slide-out crumb tray
  • Stylish curved front and shiny stainless steel exterior is perfect for your modern kitchen
  • A ready bell and automatic shutoff eases cooking
  • Reheats 26% faster and uses 76% less energy


  • Timer dial is pretty difficult to set for toast
  • Sometimes it browns the bread unevenly

Key Features:

  • 1500 watts
  • Stainless steel exterior
  • Chrome-plated knobs
  • 5 functions
  • 30-minute
  • Stay-on feature
  • Weighs 6.92 pounds

Hamilton Beach Easy Reach – Overview

Buyer’s Guide

Pizza Option

Toaster oven, in the name itself it says oven. So yes, you can bake or defrost readymade pizza in any of the Hamilton Beach toaster ovens. However, the size of the pizza varies according to the size of the oven. For example, a 4-slice toaster oven fits in 9-inch pizza perfectly, whereas, a 6-slice unit can bake a 12-inch pizza.

If you truly love baking pizza of your own then consider buying a convection toaster oven. The convection function helps to bake the crust crispy and golden brown. While the fan on the back distributes heat uniformly on all sides so that cheese on your pizza melts evenly, the heating element on the bottom ensures a crispy pizza base.

Oven Racks

Metal racks are common with any toaster oven. And these racks are perfect for toasting bread slices, bagels, etc. You can also warm foods on the metal rack. Many units also include a broiling pan or a baking pan that helps with versatile cooking. These pans help to broil crispy vegetables to sweet desserts easily.

Also, many large toaster ovens offer 2 or 3 rack positions. This positioning helps with better cooking and warming of food. Plus, you can fit big size food easily in the rack without getting top or sides messy.

Built-in Functions

Two main functions of the Hamilton Beach toaster oven are toasting and baking. But many models provide an additional broiling feature that is great for people who love broiled veggies and fish. All these settings are very easy to set as you just need to turn the knob. A large oven will comprise 3 knobs that let you set each function conveniently. Whereas a small toaster oven will have 2 knobs on the side, one to set temperature and another one to set both function and time.

Other than that, there are many built-in functions of Hamilton Beach toaster oven that helps to save energy and cook better. These settings include automatic shutoff, convection mode, bell alert, stay-on setting, slide-out crumb tray, 15 or 30-minute timer.

And while buying their oven or any other kitchen appliances you are backed by one of the best customer support. You can always get in touch with their support team to solve your queries.

Do I need to preheat a toaster oven?

You might have read many recipes that ask you to put prepared food in a preheated oven. And this raises the question of whether it is always necessary to preheat the toaster oven before you put anything inside it? No, it is not necessary or compulsory to preheat the toaster oven but chefs recommend doing so. Preheating the appliance makes the air inside hot enough for your baking, broiling, or toasting session to be perfect.

Imagine you wish to take a warm shower. You either go in the shower and wait till the water heats up or turn the shower on, wait for the water to reach the desired temperature, and then enter the shower. Similarly, this applies to your toaster oven. You already set a good warm temperature so you can get started with the further process.

Can you put aluminum foil in a toaster oven?

Using aluminum foil inside a toaster oven is quite common. Many people use them to bake foods properly. But you should use the foil carefully as it is potentially dangerous. There have been many reports of fire hazards caused because of aluminum foil. But that does not mean you cannot use one. You can surely put aluminum foil in an oven but with a few things in mind.

  • First thing is to check whether your appliance allows the use of aluminum foil or not. Even if there is no specific mention of using a foil, you can use it with caution. But do not put aluminum foil in an appliance that does not support their use.
  • Always but a quality aluminum foil that is safe to use in toaster ovens rather than settling for some cheap quality material. A good quality foil will help you bake hard ingredients like potato thoroughly without raising the inside temperature.
  • Tightly wrap aluminum foil around the baking ingredients as it helps heat penetrate into them easily. Also, make sure that that it does not touch any of the heating elements.
  • If your toaster oven is safe to use aluminum foils then you can cover the crumb tray with it. This will keep the bottom tray new and hygienic for multiple uses. You can simply discard the foil and lay a new one to process different batches of food.

Can you cook anything in a toaster oven?

Don’t go by its size as a toaster oven is more versatile than you think. It can perform all most all functions that a conventional oven offers. You can bake, broil, and toast ingredients conveniently in a toaster oven. A huge difference between both of them is size. A toaster oven is compact, more like a countertop appliance as compared to a conventional model that is generally large and often installed in the wall.

Also, it takes more time to preheat a large oven while you can quickly finish preheating session with toaster ovens. But a built-in oven offers a large space to fit a good quantity of ingredients at a time while you can only fit a small batch with toaster ovens. However, this is not an issue as long as you’re making a meal for up to 5 people. You can cook a casserole, roast up to 5-pound chicken, bake a 10-inch diameter pizza, make cookies, reheat leftovers, and even cook frozen fries in a toaster oven.

Also Read:


Make crispy toasts and soft cakes with the best Hamilton Beach toaster oven. A 4-slice model is perfect for a family who loves to have warm toasts and bagels in the morning. Plus, many convectional ovens let you bake the pizza crust and other bread just like the store-bought ones. You should go for a toaster oven with convection if you love baking homemade pizza. The cooking options are endless with a good quality toaster oven like Hamilton Beach. So go ahead and make some space on your countertop for a 4-slice toaster oven.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here